Since mid-2021, the IOTA Foundation was involved in Gaia-X, an EU-wide project on European IT infrastructure. Now IOTA is saying goodbye to Gaia-X. The potential of the cooperation was questionable anyway.
The IOTA Foundation likes to rush ahead with optimistic announcements about cooperations and project participation. But when one of such initiatives turns out worse than hoped, IOTA’s communication is often less transparent. The most recent example is Gaia-X: In the summer of 2021, IOTA was still praising its participation in the project on IT infrastructure in the EU as exemplary and was still defending Gaia-X in May 2022, when even the German Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology was already doubting its funding. But now IOTA CEO Dominik Schiener has announced Gaia-X’s withdrawal in an online discussion.
Schiener writes that Gaia-X is in some ways “too political” and a “waste of resources.” At the IOTA Foundation, staff had to be cut recently, and in the current austerity measures, the side project Shimmer (SMR) with planned launch on September 28 has priority. But skepticism about whether IOTA is doing itself a favor with politically desired projects is nothing new. The argument is often put forward that publicly financed IT projects cannot seriously compete with the offerings of the US giants such as Amazon and Microsoft anyway. At Gaia-X, IOTA had most recently focused on Mobility 2.0 – but this topic has long since reached the industry as well.
It is not yet known whether IOTA still intends to publish a final report on Gaia-X. At ENSURESEC on security in e-commerce, the IOTA Foundation had presented such a report at the beginning of September. However, it should also be noted here: The EU project has succeeded in offering IT tools to small and medium-sized enterprises. But it remains questionable whether these small and medium-sized enterprises will actually dock with ENSURESEC or prefer to continue relying on commercial IT security solutions in practice.
Conclusion: IOTA and publicly funded projects – euphoria fades away
For a while, it looked like the IOTA Foundation was going to rely more on publicly funded project money for its funding. With the completion of ENSURESEC and the withdrawal from Gaia-X, two such initiatives are now coming to an end, with no follow-up projects in sight. On the other hand, IOTA – as far as is known – is still on board with the EU projects EBSI and SECANT. Thus, Schiener and the IOTA community could still hope that one of these projects wanted by the EU will make a breakthrough and actually develop solutions that will be accepted by citizens and the economy.